The tribute to Teddy Kollek by George Weigel (CR, Jan. 18) was for a remarkable man who participated in the birth of Israel. Mr. Weigel, in his glowing tribute to Mayor Kollek, refers to the intifada and how it made cooperation with the Palestinians impossible. That remark reminds us that the struggle in the Middle East and for Jerusalem is one driven by two compelling narratives. Teddy Kollek represents one – the one Americans know the most about. It is the narrative of the Holocaust and the struggle of the Jews for a homeland. The other is the Palestinian narrative of the Nakbah, the Arab word for catastrophe, inflicted on the Palestinian people in 1948 and again in 1967.



